President’s Column: Ineffable Twaddlings

Follow up on Your Word is My Delight: A Catholic Writers Retreat

I’m still coming down from a spiritual high from our retreat in Michigan. It was so amazing, I am having difficulty finding the words to describe it (tough, for a writer). Ten people attended from many parts of the country, some from as far as Massachusetts, Arizona, and Florida. The majority, of course, were from Michigan. I have to admit I was concerned, at first, at the small group we had. But, as it turned out, that simply made it more intimate and focused.

Here’s the whole retreat gang from left to right: Margaret Realy, Dr. Jean Lee, Patrice Davignon, Gerard Webster, Ann Lewis, Pat Gohn, Michael Diebold, Kathy Schiffer, Helen Hart, Erin McCole-Cupp, Kathleen McGuire, Lillah Olson, Father Charles Irivin, Julie Herridge and Father Tucker Cordani.

CWG Member Pat Gohn was our key presenter who gave us some thoughtful reflections on Psalm 119, the documents of the Church, and our vocations as writers.

Margaret’s good friend David Krajewski also did a great talk on the Joyful Mysteries and “vocation” (I will be posting this soon in our forums for people to read.) The other speakers were fabulous, too. Kathy Schiffer and I conducted critique sessions that were small, inspiring, and effective.

It was a time to pray, write, and reflect in an absolutely gorgeous natural environment. The gardens that Margaret planned and coordinated on the grounds were breathtaking. Here are some photos.

Margaret gave us a tour of her lovely gardens the first day. This is she walking us through one of the several memorial gardens on the property.








This is a shot of the Calvary Garden through the autumn-colored trees:








And this is the bell tower of the monastary that the monks would ring throughout the day, now enhanced by Margaret’s green thumb:










One night, Margaret pointed out a cute little green tree frog to me, and later I could hear one singing outside my window. Tree frogs! I didn’t know they had tree frogs in Michigan, and I grew up there!

By the end of the five days, all of us were great friends, praying, inspiring, supporting, crying, hugging, and singing songs by the campfire.

Because this retreat was so successful, we plan to have another in late April of 2013 – information, costs and exact dates to come. We will only offer retreats every other year so folks can save up to be able to attend both the retreat and our August conference in the same year.

Pray and work, folks. Ora et labora!

Need Your Feedback TONIGHT in CWG Chats

Just a little reminder going to the blogshpere…

Tonight, we are meeting in the CWG chat room to discuss CWG Chats!

What would you like to discuss at CWG guest chats? Got guest ideas? Got questions? Bring them to the CWG chat–What to do with our chat–TONIGHT (Tuesday) a 9 pm Eastern. We want to hear from YOU! http://www.catholicwritersguild.com/index.php?name=Content_2&pid=1

Working With An Editor


All authors need an editor. Self-published authors should not publish a manuscript without hiring a competent editor to improve and polish it.

For the purposes of this article, an editor is someone who suggests changes in overall plot, setting, characters and theme. I am not talking about a copy-editor (although copy-editors are important).

Before I started writing fiction, I had written many non-fiction articles. I mistakenly thought fiction would be easier. The first draft of my debut novel, Emily’s Hope, was so bad that when I gave part of it to my kind (and honest) husband to read, his response was, “You’re not going to let anyone read this, are you?”

Admittedly, I was crushed. I hired an editor and over the next two years, she helped me to take a badly written first draft and transform it into a much better novel. She helped me not only to improve my writing style, but to also create a convincing narrative voice.

Here are a few key points to remember when working with an editor:

Be Humble: If you think your book is going to be a Nobel prize-winning book or that it’s the best book every written…well, it probably isn’t, not yet anyway. It may have the potential of being a great book but, generally speaking, most books need a lot of polishing and editing to get it to the stage of being “great.”

Like many authors, I spend more time polishing and editing than I do writing the first draft.

Consider and Reflect on Each Criticism/Suggestion: It may take hours or days of reflection to realize that most of the editor’s ideas will actually make the book better.

Authors tend to be blind to the defects in our own works. Some of us can be rigid with regard to what we want the story or characters to be. For example, in my second novel (In Name Only, a historical romance), the first draft was entirely from the main female character’s point of view (POV).

The editor said that she understood why I chose that particular POV, but either I needed to include the major male characters’ POVs or find another way for the reader to understand the male characters better.

I initially rejected the idea of including the male characters’ POVs. Then as time passed and I reflected, I admitted that she might be right. As it turned out, writing from a male POV was also great fun. This novel went on to win a Gold medal in the IPPY awards and is currently an Amazon Kindle Top 100 bestseller in Religious Fiction.

Resist the Urge to be Defensive: This is where I have the most trouble. But then again, that’s my personality. Even now, when I read my editor’s suggested changes, I have to resist the urge to be defensive.

You Don’t Have to Agree with Everything: Sometimes, the editor will suggest changes the author is reluctant to make. If, after reflection, you still feel strongly about keeping things the same, talk it over with the editor. I find I usually agree with about 85 percent of the suggested edits and I disregard the rest.

Keep in mind that your editor is not being paid to be nice or to make you feel good; he or she is being paid to make your book a quality book.

Trust Your Editor: If you don’t trust your editor, you should probably find a different editor.

Working with an editor can be a challenging experience. However, if you exercise humility, consider and reflect on each edit, be open to change, resist the urge to be defensive and trust your editor, you will hopefully produce a great quality book.

What are your experiences working with an editor? Can you think of anything to add?

Leave a comment below before Friday, October 14th to be entered to win one of two free Kindle copies of my new book, Stealing Jenny.

Ellen Gable Hrkach is the vice president of the Catholic Writers Guild. She is the award-winning author of In Name Only, a Catholic romance and now an Amazon Kindle bestseller (top 100 Religious Fiction). Her new book is Stealing Jenny which is a contemporary pro-life suspense novel. Her website is www.ellengable.com. She and her husband and five sons live in Pakenham, ON Canada.

Pondering Grammar

Let me begin by mentioning a writer’s three first cousins, metaphor, simile and personification (oops–I guess I  just personified them). Okay–Mr. Metaphor is a comparison of two dissimilar objects or actions that have something in common. Better yet, it is a comparison of two separate things as if they were alike (Uh-oh–is that crossing into simile territory?). Wait a minute–if I say, “My car’s engine sounds like my cranky neighbor”— is that a simile or a  personification or both? Maybe it is a metaphor also?

I don’t know about you guys but this stuff can drive me crazy. That’s why I really don’t care. When I write I use metaphors, similes and personifications all the time without ever thinking about them. If someone would ask me to define a metaphor I would probably go blank because I would immediately start thinking about the cousins; simile and personification. Not being able to separate them from each other I would wish I were like a turtle so I could easily stuff my head inside myself (is that a simile?). 


What about lay and lie? Oh sure, that’s easy. Lay is a transitive verb and always takes a direct object. Lie is an intransitive verb and NEVER takes a direct object. What does that mean? I know, I know, use the “what rule”. But wait!—The fact is, some verbs can be transitive and intransitive. You know what, I OBJECT!

Of course there are indicative moods and imperative moods and superlative adverbs and I could go on and on and when I get to compound additive subjects and superlative verbs I need a reality check so I turn on the TV to get back to the “real” world of English grammar and flick on the Sopranos. Fuhgedaboutit.


Here’s the thing. I was taught English grammar and usage by the Ursuline Nuns and the Marist Brothers. I hated it. But I loved composition and creative writing, anything that required just writing stuff without having to define or diagram (remember that?) every sentence. When I did that I had to know grammar and usage. And,  I guess I did. Somehow, someway, I had been taught and never realized it was happening. I don’t know how they did it but all I can say is–GOD BLESS EM.

CWG Board News September 30

As Vice President of the Catholic Writers Guild, it is my responsibility to share board news on the fifth Friday (whenever that occurs).

Last Friday on this blog, in sharing what the CWG Board discussed at our recent Skype meeting, Karina said, “Officer Elections are in November! We discussed it and we will stay on as your officer cadre if you wish (though Karina would like to be committee coordinator and Dave would be secretary). However, that’s if no one else wants to run. Check out the forums for a list of duties and to nominate yourself or others.”

I just want to reiterate that the CWG Board members are willing to continue as members of the Board, if no one else wishes to run. If you are interested in running, please check out the forums to nominate yourself.

One of the great things about the 21st century is that we can participate in a Skype board meeting without leaving the comfort of our homes. We begin and end each meeting with a prayer. As a member of the board, I am able to view the agenda before the meeting and add any topics I think should be discussed. During the meeting, it’s easy to follow along with the Google Wave agenda and see changes which are being recorded in the minutes.

Being part of the CWG Board has been an interesting and worthwhile experience. As Vice President, my duties are not as numerous as some of the other board members, but I enjoy working with Ann, Karina, Anne and Dave.

Ellen Gable Hrkach is the Vice President of the Catholic Writers Guild. She is the award-winning author of “In Name Only,” a Catholic romance and now an Amazon Kindle bestseller (top 100 Religious Fiction). Her new book is Stealing Jenny, which is a contemporary pro-life suspense novel. Her website is www.ellengable.com. She and her husband and five sons live in Pakenham, ON Canada.

"Don’t Write What you Know" (huh)

(A Thanks to Jean Heimann for posting the referenced essay on the CWO. Found it fascinating)

The Atlantic Magazine published an essay by Bret Johnston titled, “Don’t Write What You Know”. Mr.Johnston teaches an introductory fiction workshop at Harvard University. He passes out a bullet list to the students citing things that they should avoid. The final item on the list is the title to today’s blog. He states in the essay that after the students read this final item that “the idea panics his students because they have always been encouraged to “write what you know”.

Naturally—I panicked because I too, have heard this vicious, insidious type of encouragement –for years. I always assumed that what I wrote was somehow, in someway, coming from something I knew. I mean, if I take some words and use them to create some outlandish,  multi-colored space monkey who speaks several languages and eats yogurt instead of bananas, I assume that somewhere inside me I was, at one time or another, exposed to some strange monkey business and I have stretched it out into something that is non-existent and I do not even know that I  knew it in the first place. (Hey–it makes sense to me)

Mr. Johnston wrote, “an essential part of me dies when the student says, ‘What I wanted to do was—‘. The idea  of a writer wanting to do something in a story unhinges me—”  That sentence unhinged me. Don’t we want to do something when we write something? Do we not sense a purpose, a reason, a goal? If I get in the car to simply go for an unplanned ride I still have to know how to start the thing and guide it in different directions, right?

The point of all this is that sometimes (maybe many times) writing advice overloads me. Story structure, planned plot, flow, imagery, dialogue, how to do this and how not to do that. If I keep referencing all that stuff over and over all I learn is that I know less and less. My confidence wanes and it becomes reverse education. For me, I never actually know where I am going. My blank paper is my plot of land. My pencil/pen is my dump truck which is loaded with all the material I need to build my “dream house” from footers to finished trim and paint. I empty the dump truck on the paper and then I begin to sort everything  out and put it together. I do not think I could do it if I did not know what I know. Trust me, I will not paint the drywall until it is installed, taped and finished. There are many who will not like the color of the paint I chose. No problem, they can paint their house any color they like.

President’s Column: Ineffable Twaddlings

It is the end of the month (almost) and I want to dedicate this space to a quick wrap-up of our very successful writers conference in Valley Forge as well as tell you about our upcoming Retreat.

The Catholic Writers Conference LIVE was a smashing success. We had 40 paid attendees plus an uncountable number of CMN attendees who came to our presentations, plus 17 volunteers and 20 presenters who all added up to a power-house event. Our booth was well-represented with many, many terrific books and authors signing them. Our first-ever Catholic Arts and Letters Awards (Lilies) were presented to Michelle Buckman for Rachel’s Contrition and Regina Doman for Alex O’Donnell and the 40 Cyberthieves in front of all the retailers and vendors who attended the trade show breakfast banquet. CWG is tremendously grateful to all our presenters, volunteers, attendees and, most of all, Our Lord for being a part of event. We couldn’t have done it without you. (Meanwhile – we need volunteers to help administrate the CALA for this year – please contact Karina Fabian at karina (at) fabianspace.com if you are interested.)

One very important note on the conference: We need your input!! There’s talk of changing the dates for the Catholic Writers Conference Live next year. Would you take this 3-question survey to help us decide? Follow this link and answer the three questions and it’ll help a great deal!

Our next big event is Your Word is My Delight: Catholic Writers Retreat – October 5-9, 2011 at the St. Francis Retreat Center in DeWitt, Michigan. I did send out a separate e-mailing on this event, so many of you have this information, but I want to reiterate that it looks to be a fantastic experience that is different from our writers conferences. With this retreat, we’ll work on our souls, contemplate God’s calling to us as writers and grow as writers through one-on-one critique sessions. And, because this is a writers retreat, you will be given a lot of time to just write! Please consider coming, and pass on this information to those you think might be interested. Post it on your blogs, twitter and facebook. If we don’t get more registrations for this event quickly, it may have to be canceled and we’d hate for that to happen.

Meanwhile – keep praying for our success, and God bless you all!

"God writes straight with crooked lines"

When I see the screen on my cell phone flashing the name, “Jumbo”, I cringe. Now, please don’t get me wrong, Jumbo Feeney and I have been best friends since Hector was a pup. I love the guy but—sometimes he just drives me nuts. Why? Because he has a unique opinion on every topic known to humankind. I mean this 6’4″, 250 pound, ruddy faced bruiser with hands the size of ham hocks knows it all. Anyway, when I see his name staring at me from that little screen I usually do not answer because I need some time to pray and mentally prepare for the event. It usually takes about ten or fifteen minutes and then I return the call. If I just answer he is already in mid-sentence and I will not have a clue as to what he is talking about and he’ll want my opinion even though he never hears it anyway. Then he’ll bust out in his raucous, deep belly laugh and–well, trust me, it is an experience.

So Saturday morning I see Jumbo’s name flashing on the cell phone screen. What do I do? I ignore my own rule and answer the phone. As I flip open the phone I call myself an idiot and then begin to listen because Jumbo is in mid-sentence. “Petie, (he calls me Petie) you’re sitting down, right? I mean this is BIG—really BIG.”

He starts laughing and I don’t sit down. “C’mon Jumbo, what? What is it?”

“Guess where I’m going tomorrow? C’mon man, guess.”

“NO idea Jumbo. I do know where you’re not going.”

“There you go Petie, you think you’re so smart. Well, guess what? WRONG! I am going. I am going to Mass tomorrow. Think you’re so smart. Well, gotcha.”

“Gotcha” was a good word. Jumbo had not been to church in, who knows, a VERY longtime. Throughout all of those years, he has been trying to convince me that whether a person went to church or not made no difference in their spiritual life. I had always held my ground and refused to discuss the topic with him. His talking to me was his way of trying to convince himself he was right, so—I just would listen. It was not easy, trust me. I was guessing that he had finally convinced himself that he was wrong.

“Petie, you there? Say something. Anything. Hope the news did not make you drop dead or something.” More raucous laughter.

“Uh, no Jumbo. Just have a few chest pains and I’m hyperventilating a bit. Otherwise. I’m fine. So tell me, what happened. It’s been a long time for you.”

“Yeah Petie, that’s for sure. A long time. I just think it’s time for me, that’s all.”

“Jumbo, God writes straight with crooked lines, doesn’t he? We all follow our own path. I’m not saying anything. I’ll call you Monday and see how it went, okay?”

“Petie, you didn’t ask me if I went to confession.”

“Not going there Jumbo. None of my business.”

“Good job, Petie, good job. That was just a little test for you anyway.”

“Hey Jumbo.”

“What?”

“Love ya man.”

E-Books: The Future of Self-Publishing

Imagine a future where kids don’t have to carry around a heavy backpack for all their books, merely a small thin bag to tote around. Imagine a future where ALL books cost under $10, with many being 2.99 or under and millions available for FREE. Imagine a future where an author can receive 70 percent of the royalties…

That future is NOW!

Making my books available on Amazon Kindle was the single best marketing tool I’ve ever used. Recently, both my new book, Come My Beloved, and my second novel, In Name Only, were in the top 100 in Amazon Kindle Books on the same day!

With tens of thousands of Kindle (and other) e-readers being sold daily, they are fast becoming the wave of the future! The Kindle reader is also available as a free application for PC, iPod, iPad and iPhone, so it’s not necessary to spend money to be able to read a Kindle book.

Amazon currently offers Kindle publishers 70 percent royalty (for most books) and there are virtually no up front costs. Of course, there are other advantages to having your self-published book available on the Amazon Kindle.

Advantage #1: Receive More Exposure
In this recession, many people have become careful with their money. They will not pay $15 for a print book, but they will likely pay 2.99 for a digital book.

The more books you sell on Kindle the more book lists it shows up in.

For example, my Kindle books have been purchased by thousands of people in the last several months. Each individual person has purchased other books. These books have Amazon pages and my books show up on those book pages.

Advantage #2: Receive More Money With No Financial Output
The beauty of e-books is that there are no printing costs. Currently, Amazon US and Amazon Great Britain offer 70 percent royalty option. You just need to make sure you click that option when you register your book for publication. (This is one of the advantages unique to self-published authors. Publishers generally jack up the price for Kindle books. Self-published authors can offer their books for much less and still receive a decent royalty per book.)

Advantage #3: Gain More Fans
I am regularly selling hundreds of Kindle books per month and these figures are increasing by the week. That may not be a big deal for famous authors, but for little ole’ me, it is incredible!

Advantage #4: Sell More Print books by Selling More E-books
Because your book is listed on many more Amazon sites, this gives your print book more exposure as well.

Whether you’re a first-time author or an established writer, there are many advantages of putting your book on Kindle: you can receive more exposure, make more money, sell more books (without the financial costs of printing) and gain more fans. E-books are the future of self-publishing.

Next month: E-Books: The Future of Self-Publishing Part II…Some Practical Considerations


Ellen Gable Hrkach is the vice president of the Catholic Writers Guild. She is the award-winning author of “In Name Only,” a Catholic romance. Her new book is called “Come My Beloved: Inspiring Stories of Catholic Courtship.” Her website is www.ellengable.com She and her husband and five sons live in Pakenham, ON Canada.

Question: Does Safety trump Forgiveness?

Maybe this is not the proper forum for this but I need some input from traditional minded Catholics about something that has been eating away at me. I need some different (if possible) takes on this and, out of desperation, thought I would take a shot and throw it out here. What better place than the CWG, right?

Okay, here goes. In their justified and necessary quest to prevent further scandals in the church the USCCB adopted the Charter for the Protection of Children & Young People (including vulnerable adults) which was modeled after guidelines established by the Dallas Charter of 2002. The bishops had to act and they did a marvelous job addressing the issues and implementing safeguards etc.  So, what is my problem?

As a Eucharistic Minister who visits the home bound I was required to go through a two phase process to remain eligible to continue in this ministry. Part A) was a level 2 background check which included complete fingerprinting run through the FBI data-base. Part B) was the requirement to attend a “safe environment” training seminar. At this seminar a packet of various papers was handed out and included in these papers were three sheets listing 47 different offenses that immediately eliminated a person from any diocesan job (paid or volunteer) where children or vulnerable adults might be. Then one of the moderators happily explained how the FBI check had turned up a man with a DUI from 20 years earlier and how he was immediately relieved of his volunteer position as a school bus driver for field trips and other functions. This guy had not had a drink or been in any trouble since the DUI. I immediately was upset with this and asked about “forgiveness” and was told  that “we HAVE to protect the children”. Look, I’m a parent and a grandparent. I know about protecting kids. This to me was over the top.

Second case had to do with a 29 year old man who I know very well. This guy has a learning disability and was hired as a dishwasher at a local Catholic high school. His problem was that, when he was 19, he and some of his teen aged buddies got drunk and this guy passed out behind a local restaurant. His friends left him there, the manager  saw him and called the police and when the police tried to wake him he shoved the one cop. Result: “resisting arrest” and “battery on a police officer”. The FBI check pulled up these charges and he lost his dish washing job, just like that. Since then he has wound up being treated at the local mental health clinic and is severely depressed and on medication.

My question to anyone who may read this is; Does “Safety trump Forgiveness”? Did Jesus tell the woman caught in adultery to “go and sin no more but stay away from kids and vulnerable adults for the rest of your life”. I don’t think so. Your convicted pedophiles and sexual deviants cannot be allowed around kids. That’s a no-brainer. But,  have we stepped over the line with this and are we, as catholics, unforgiving those who have charges against them that can be of no threat to anyone. Safe Environment predicated by Zero Tolerance seems to me to be a tool that can only lead to disenfranchising many catholics and even causing scandal by rejecting forgiveness. Help me out here, PLEASE.